CD308: A Chaotic Finale

CD308: A Chaotic Finale

Jan 6, 2025

The 118th Congress came to an unexpectedly — though not necessarily surprisingly — chaotic end. In this episode, hear about all the drama that averted a government shutdown, learn what became law, and examine what could have become law if it weren’t for Elon Musk.

Please Support Congressional Dish – Quick Links

  • Contribute monthly or a lump sum via PayPal
  • Support Congressional Dish via Patreon (donations per episode)
  • Send Zelle payments to: Donation@congressionaldish.com
  • Send Venmo payments to: @Jennifer-Briney
  • Send Cash App payments to: $CongressionalDish or Donation@congressionaldish.com
  • Use your bank’s online bill pay function to mail contributions to: 5753 Hwy 85 North, Number 4576, Crestview, FL 32536.

Please make checks payable to Congressional Dish

Thank you for supporting truly independent media!

Background Sources

Recommended Congressional Dish Episodes

CD280: Corporate Junk Fees

Rep. Rosa DeLauro Letter

“DeLauro in Letter to Congressional Leadership: Musk Chaos in Government Funding Process Protects His Chinese Investments.” Rosa DeLauro. December 20, 2024.

Kay Granger

“Answers finally surface on absent GOP lawmaker.” Jamie Dupree. December 23, 2024. Regular Order on Substack.

Appropriations Status Table

Paris Hilton Project

This is Paris: The Real Story of Paris Hilton.

Ethics Reports

“Report of the Committee on Ethics in the Matter of Allegations Relating to Representative Matt Gaetz.” December 23, 2024. House Ethics Committee.

“Report of the Committee on Ethics in the Matter of Allegations Relating to Representative Michael McCaul.” December 23, 2024. House Ethics Committee.

“Report of the Committee on Ethics in the Matter of Allegations Relating to Representative Victoria Spartz.” November 12, 2024. House Ethics Committee.

The CR

H.R.10545 – American Relief Act, 2025

Laws

S. 1351: Stop Institutional Child Abuse Act

S. 4610: A bill to amend title 36, United States Code, to designate the bald eagle as the national bird

Bills

H.R. 4310: Youth Poisoning Protection Act

H.R. 4984: D.C. Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Stadium Campus Revitalization Act

S. 4569: TAKE IT DOWN Act

H.R. 3950: TICKET Act

H.R. 675: Secure Space Act of 2023

H.R.1: Lower Energy Costs Act

Audio Sources

Safeguarding the Homeland: Examining Conflicts of Interest in Federal Contracting to Protect America’s Future

Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
September 24, 2024

Watch on YouTube

Witnesses:

  • Jessica Tillipman, Associate Dean for Government Procurement Law Studies & Government Contracts Advisory Council and Distinguished Professorial Lecturer in Government Contracts Law, Practice & Policy, George Washington University Law School
  • Dr. Rush Doshi, Starr Senior Fellow for Asia Studies Council on Foreign Relations and Assistant Professor, Georgetown University
  • Clark Packard, Research Fellow, Herbert A. Stiefel Center for Trade Policy Studies, Cato Institute
  • Bryan Riley, Director, Free Trade Initiative National Taxpayers Union

Clips

22:15 Sen. Gary Peters (D-MI): Over the past decade, there have been alarming reports of federal contractors who are simultaneously promoting competing interests, including those of foreign adversaries, interests that directly contradict our national security needs and hurt our economic competitiveness. For example, in the summer of 2023 in one of the largest intrusions of US government cloud services, Chinese state-backed hackers gained access to the emails of high level officials, compromising the information security of US officials who work on national and economic security matters. This attack has raised serious concerns that China-backed hackers were able to steal this information because of the service provider’s partnership with a Chinese entity while they were providing services to the United States Government at exactly the same time.

23:10 Sen. Gary Peters (D-MI): In 2015, a consulting firm responsible for advising the US government on national security strategy, cyber security and cutting edge technology was simultaneously advising Chinese state run enterprises. And this consulting work for Chinese enterprises involved China’s naval fleet and Chinese government efforts to raise its profile and strengthen its position in power globally, a goal in direct competition with American interests.

23:55 Sen. Gary Peters (D-MI): These examples demonstrate the need to strengthen our laws, specifically around the disclosure of foreign ties, and particularly where federal contractors are providing services to authoritarian governments who seek to bolster their economic and geographic assets in competition with our nation.

25:10 Sen. Gary Peters (D-MI): In 2022, my bipartisan bill, the Preventing Organizational Conflicts of Interest in Federal Acquisition Act, was signed into law. The bill seeks to end conflicts of interest from federal contracts that provide critical services to the American people. It directed the Federal Acquisition Regulatory Council, or FAR Council, to provide clear guidance to agencies and federal contractors on ways to identify, mitigate and even avoid conflicts of interest. Despite being signed into law nearly two years ago, the FAR Council is late in issuing guidance required by my law, which is why yesterday, I led the co-sponsors of this legislation in a letter pressing for quick action to issue this desperately needed guidance.

1:09:10 Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO): Since 2008, the McKinsey Company has done nearly a billion dollars in consulting work for the United States government, a billion dollars, and its top client has been the Defense Department. In fact, it’s got contracts with the Defense Department, with the US Department of the Navy, with the Homeland Security Department, with Customs and Border Patrol. I think in 2021 alone, McKenzie had Defense Department or other security agency contracts worth $850 million. It’s absolutely extraordinary. And yet, at the same time, they’re also doing business with the Chinese government. They are simultaneously taking a billion dollars from the United States and its security agencies, and also getting money from not just China in general, from the Chinese government and Chinese controlled entities. Explain to us why that is a problem. I think any normal American who’s sitting out there and hears that would be absolutely outraged by it, and rightly so. Why are they getting taxpayer money advising our military and simultaneously advising the Chinese military? Just explain to us, why is this a national security concern? Dr. Rush Doshi: Well, thank you, Senator Hawley, I agree this is a national security concern. I would go further. I mean, the nature of the work that McKinsey did reportedly involved helping China consider how to out compete US technology firms, how to strengthen Made in China 2025. The goal was to help them advance their goals for technological dominance. And that is directly at odds with the interest not just of the US government, but also of the corporate clients they had in the United States that they were also advising. So there’s a clear conflict of interest there. And it’s also, you know, the kind of conflict of interest that even if McKinsey had exercised better judgment about the projects it took on, other firms doing business in China are getting raided by the Chinese government. Oftentimes, that means that their data is no longer secure, and if they have us client data on those servers, well that’s now Chinese data. So there’s a lot of concerns, I think, that we can we can raise here. One is the nature of the work. Another is being a vector for the transfer of information and data. And there’s a third concern too, that some of these firms have mutually irreconcilable obligations to the United States and to China. China is basically saying, if you want to comply with the subpoena from this committee, you can’t, because we have a data security law saying you can’t. That’s three different kinds of conflicts beyond the ones, Senator, that you just identified.

1:12:05 Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO): You know, interestingly, I recently obtained a document related to a contract, just to give one example, involving semiconductors. So semiconductors, McKinsey entered into a contract with the US government, our Defense Advanced Research Project Agency (DARPA), in 2021 related to semiconductors. The DoD asked McKinsey if there was any conflict that they might have with the Chinese government. According to these documents recently released to me pursuant to a FOIA request, McKinsey submitted documentation that said that there were no conflicts, no conflicts at all. And in fact, as we now know, they were simultaneously advising the Chinese government on a very similar project.

1:12:45 Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO): The Chairman and I wrote to the GAO asking for an analysis of the conflict of interest law and analysis of the procurement and contract awarding process to see if there were any strictures or limitations in current law that would prevent companies like McKinsey from simultaneously making billions from the United States and making billions on China. That report has just come back just a couple of days ago, and what it shows is that there are no such restrictions in United States law currently.

1:22:10 Dr. Rush Doshi: It’s not just a question of whether they contract with the Department of Defense. It’s a number of federal agencies that are going to contract with these consulting firms. All of that should be considered. The second thing that I’m worried about is not just our consulting firms that are doing contracting with the federal government and the Chinese government, it’s our technology service providers, because the US government relies on these technology service providers for critical services: the Department of Defense, our defense industrial base, our water sector, our power sector, transportation, telecommunications. So if we have a conflict of interest where those companies go to China, share their source code or enter into a joint venture which can compromise that service, it affects all of us.

1:23:40 Dr. Rush Doshi: When it comes to technology service providers, the stakes are so high that we want these companies to think from a risk perspective, that the risk of partnering with the PRC, or working with the PRC, or giving in to their demands is not going to be worth it given the significant revenue hit that they’ll take from being cut off, not just from the Department of Defense, but a number of US government agencies. So I want that balance to be in a more conservative direction.


Music

Tired of Being Lied To by David Ippolito

Editing

Pro Podcast Solutions

Production Assistance

Clare Kuntz Balcer


Check out this episode!

Support the Show

  • Patreon: for an uncensored experience.
  • PayPal (click the "Make This a Monthly Donation" checkbox to start a subscription)
  • Zelle: Donation@congressionaldish.com
  • CashApp: $CongressionalDish or Donation@congressionaldish.com
  • Popmoney: Donation@congressionaldish.com
  • Venmo: @Jennifer-Briney
  • Bitcoin: 3NFBJGSAnr1XbuCk6THvbsGmn2uVeumR6s
  • Ethereum: 0xA311450A3b2198dd312b7109C295933452634278
  • Litecoin: MQ2uBHu8v12rwq9HHwD95HD6VsgpcHuqjs

Check icon

Donate by check payable to:

Congressional Dish
5753 Hwy 85 North #4576
Crestview, FL 32536
(339) 707-0307